Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Confusion Caused By Suspicious Deed Conveying Fractional Interests To Bankrupt People Recorded Day Before F'closure Enough To Void Subsequent Sale

In Fresno, California, The Fresno Bee reports:

  • A bankruptcy judge on Wednesday reversed the foreclosure of the landmark Security Bank building on Fresno's Fulton Mall, giving its owners more time to find a buyer or settle its debts. Judge Whitney Rimel agreed with the building's owners, Fresno Pacific Towers Inc., that the foreclosure by East West Bank was tainted by a forged deed of trust and proceedings in another bankruptcy case in Los Angeles.

  • Fresno Pacific Towers owes $5.2 million to East West Bank, and filed for bankruptcy on Jan. 18 to try to prevent the bank from foreclosing. But the bank held a foreclosure auction later that day for the 16-story, 86-year-old building. The bank was the only bidder, with an offer of $1.9 million. Within hours, the bank recorded a title change with the county.

  • Rimel's ruling will force East West Bank to reconvey the title back to the ownership group. In a statement Wednesday evening, building co-owner and manager Saundra King said she was grateful for the ruling.

***

  • Ravi Jain, an attorney for Fresno Pacific Towers Inc., said East West Bank received approval for the foreclosure from another bankruptcy court based on a forged second deed. That deed -- recorded in Fresno County -- assigned interest in the building to several parties who had filed for bankruptcy in Los Angeles last summer.

  • Fresno Pacific Towers president John E. King testified Wednesday that the signature on the deed was not his. He and his sister, Saundra King, both said they knew nothing about the Los Angeles bankruptcy case until after the building was foreclosed.

  • But there were earlier signs of trouble. East West Bank declared the building in default last summer, and a foreclosure sale was initially set for Nov. 18.

  • Saundra King testified that on Nov. 16, she hired a Southern California firm, ASND Inc., to try to delay the sale. She said she and her brother sought more time to find a buyer and settle their debt to East West Bank before the bank foreclosed. King said she paid ASND about $5,000 in advance.

  • On Nov. 17, a day after King hired ASND and a day before the auction, the forged deed was filed with the Fresno County Recorder's Office. The Nov. 18 auction was postponed, and an auctioneer said the delay was because of a bankruptcy filing. According to Jain, the auctioneer was referring to the Los Angeles bankruptcy case.

  • Saundra King said she didn't learn about the forged deed until later in November. But she said "it didn't click that there would be a connection" between the document and ASND. She said she soon reported the forged deed to federal law-enforcement investigators.

  • A second auction date in December was also canceled, again because of a bankruptcy which King said she knew nothing about. The Kings said it wasn't until January, after the bank took back the building, that they learned that there was a bankruptcy case in Los Angeles and a court order allowing East West Bank to foreclose.

  • East West Bank's attorney, Thomas Geher, told the court it was obvious that ASND acted as an agent for the Kings and filed the fraudulent deed as a stalling tactic. "To believe ASND is not behind this is naive," Geher said. "The deed of trust was filed when the contract was signed," he added. "That's no coincidence. ... The debtor put all this in motion."

  • Rimel, however, gave the benefit of the doubt to the Kings and said she "cannot conclude fraudulent intent by Mr. or Ms. King." She said the Kings' contract with ASND, resembles "foreclosure prevention schemes ... that have taken advantage of hundreds of thousands of people."(1) Because Fresno Pacific Towers Inc. was never notified of the Los Angeles proceedings, Rimel added, the owners were deprived of an opportunity to argue against the foreclosure order in that case.

For the story, see Fresno landmark's foreclosure reversed (Owners of Security Bank get time to find buyer or settle debt).

(1) The hiring of a foreclosure rescue operator on the eve of a foreclosure sale to stall the sale in exchange for a payment of $5,000, coupled with the almost immediate recording of a suspicious deed of trust to multiple people who are already involved in ongoing bankruptcy proceedings in another jurisdiction certainly points to a possible fractional interest deed transfer, foreclosure rescue bankruptcy scam, as Judge Rimel correctly points out.

See Final Report Of The Bankruptcy Foreclosure Scam Task Force for a discussion of fractional interest deed transfer scams and other foreclosure scams involving the abuse of the bankruptcy courts (available online courtesy of the Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review).

Go here for other posts on fractional interest deed transfer, foreclosure rescue bankruptcy scams.

No comments: